The short version
- One score out of 5 per room, built from five factors.
- Deals are checked with the operator; exclusive deals are marked on the card.
- Licences are printed only when we have opened the regulator's register entry.
- We do not publish payout times or traffic numbers we have not recorded ourselves.
- Operators cannot buy a score.
The five factors
| Factor | What we look at | Where it comes from |
|---|---|---|
| Value of the deal | Welcome offer and its release terms, rakeback scale, rake races, freerolls, missions | The operator's promotion pages, confirmed with the operator |
| Player traffic | Whether tables and tournaments run at common stakes and hours; the network a room belongs to | The lobby, and the network the room plays on |
| Withdrawal speed | Cash-out methods, minimums, any stated processing rules | The cashier and the operator's terms |
| Software quality | Desktop, browser and phone clients, stability, HUD policy, anonymous tables | Our own use of the client |
| Community feedback | What PokerDeals readers and members report, and complaints that come up again and again | Messages to us and the rooms' public channels |
We do not publish a fixed weight for each factor yet. A deal can lift a room that is average elsewhere, and a serious problem in one area can pull a strong room down. When we settle on fixed weights, they will appear on this page with the date.
What the deal is worth to you
A big headline number is not automatically a good deal. We look at how a bonus is released and how long you have, because that decides how much of it a normal player actually receives. At Guts, for example, the bonus of up to €1,000 releases €5 for every €25 of rake within 60 days, so clearing it in full takes €5,000 of rake. A smaller offer with simple terms can be worth more to a part-time player.
Rakeback and rake races count for regulars. ChampionPoker has no welcome bonus at all and still scores 5.0, because rakeback up to 30% and a €10,000 monthly race return more over a year to anyone who plays volume.
Licences and how we check them
A licence number appears in a review only after we have opened the regulator's register entry ourselves. For Guts, Betsafe, NordicBet and Betsson that is the Malta Gaming Authority register. Where we cannot find an entry, the review says so and explains what to check, as in our ChampionPoker review. Where a room states no licence at all, as with several crypto rooms and club apps, we say that plainly.
A licence also affects the score. A room with no regulator gives you nowhere to complain if a balance is frozen, and that weighs on the withdrawal and feedback factors.
Things that lower a score
These points cost a room on our cards, and you will see them listed under "What could be better":
- A long list of restricted countries.
- A cashier limited to one type of payment, such as crypto only.
- Software stability problems at busy times.
- No phone app where players expect one.
- No licence or company named on the site.
- Deal terms that are hard to find or change without notice.
What we leave out
We do not print payout times, support response times or traffic figures until we have our own dated records for them. We do not quote player reviews or forum posts as facts. We do not invent tests. If a section of a review rests on the operator's word alone, the text says so.
Some cards in the "more rooms we rate" part of the list carry a score but say "Review coming soon". Those scores come from the same five factors; the written review follows later.
Why your list may differ from someone else's
Each room has a list of countries it does not accept players from, taken from its terms. The site hides those rooms for visitors from those countries. The score stays the same; only the rooms you can see change. Being on your list does not mean a room is licensed where you live.
Can operators pay for a better score?
No. Operators pay us when you sign up through our links, and that income pays for the site. It does not buy a place in the ranking or change a score. How the money works is set out on how we make money, and our wider rules are in the editorial policy.
When scores change
We review a score when a deal changes, when a room joins or leaves a network, when its licence status changes or when readers report the same problem several times. If you spot something out of date, tell us.
Questions about our ratings
Is a 5.0 room the right room for every player?
No. A high score means strong value and quality overall. Your format, stakes, country and payment methods decide which room suits you.
Do you play on the rooms you rate?
Yes, the PokerDeals team plays on the rooms we list. We still do not turn that into payout or traffic figures until we have dated records.
Real-money poker is for adults only, 18+, and our ratings are no promise of winnings.